The medical miscreants are still pushing to have their genetic countermeasures forced on us in the name of 'public health'.
It might be time to wake up from the illusion of 'public' health. Health is 100% an individual matter, because only you as an individual can determine which of two alternative outcomes is your preference. Medical interventions have an associated risk/reward quotient that is never known, but can be estimated. The choice of which risk to take with your own body is ~ by rights ~ yours alone.
The concept of 'public health' has to be finally extinguished and buried, not only based on the empirical evidence that governments murder millions, but on the principle of individual human rights.
Too many doctors humiliate and ridicule the vaccine injured. It’s abhorrent.
His lack of knowledge & education is no excuse not in the internet age. If lay people can equip themselves with information to understand vaccines harm then ‘medics’ can do the same , but it requires them to leave their egos to one side.
It's a cult and they believe this stuff with a religious fervor. There is a general tendency to ridicule anyone who dares to question the tenets of their dogma.
Or as my friends say..a bunch of c u next tuesdays..
One thing I have taken away from all of this outrage is that the medical profession as a whole is at an all time low. For me they are a necessary evil. I no longer trust them. It's as simple as that. They have allowed themselves to be used in a very cynical manner and the attitude of the "neurologist" seems to be typical I'm afraid.
There was a time up until quite recently that I held doctors in high esteem. 2020 has proven to me at any rate that most are cowards that crumpled under the slightest pressure.
There are of course a few( very few) who stood up for their patients but by and large the rest threw their patients under the bus to save their careers.
I wish their victims well but I don't expect any redress.
Is it not the time to start naming and shaming . The neurologist in this story should be named ,he should be made to answer for his ignorance and callousness. If tlhis story is true which I believe it is ,there is nothing to fear.
Patrick E Walsh's substack reporting unfortunately significantly overestimates Irish excess deaths figures. Such exaggerated claims may undermine legitimate criticism of the Covid-19 response by the Irish authorities and the need for an official inquiry.
Well, Patrick conceded in his presentation today that using CSO (2018) projections of annual deaths as a baseline results in excess deaths of 8%~9% for 2021-2022, significantly lower than his claim of 15%~18%.
For 2021-2023, using CSO (2018) projections results in excess deaths of ~7% (or ~7,000) - a far cry from the ~16,000 he normally claims.
It's not quite that his figures are not accurate, it's that his methodology is not meaningful. For ESTIMATES of excess deaths to be meaningful and realistic they must consider trends and changes in population Size, Age-Structure, and Life-Expectancy when calculating EXPECTED levels of mortality.
Because Patrick's analysis effectively ignores these aspects, he significantly over-estimates excess deaths since the pandemic. Patrick's figures for Ireland's Expected Mortality are not realistic, they are significantly low, and they ARE NOT backed by multiple others!
I remain happy to you talk you through the data by video-call if you would like.
EDIT: One area it seems likely he is right on is that excess mortality in the younger age-groups has been significantly higher than reported.
Regardless of your excess death numbers debate, just look around ! Everyone is either sick or dying suddenly, strokes, heart attacks etc my mother with parkinson's disease which has rapidly accelerated from these shots, she's gone deaf, constant uti, had tia then fell broke hip, dad also diagnosed early this year with prostate cancer! Can you answer that ! It's the poison shot they received! Imo Patrick's data is true representation of the facts ! People are dead and dying from this poison !
Sorry to hear about your mother and dad. I agree people are dead and dying from the Covid-19 vaccines. I hope legitimate criticism and analysis will not get ignored because of blatantly exaggerated claims.
They're not exaggerated imo ! Open your eyes..the people in the 1800s when a vax was rolled out didn't have stats or data but just observed people especially children dying post shot ! That's good enough for me ..I look at RIP every day..who ever heard of died suddenly and unexpectedly pre 2020? Go and request a debate with Patrick then if you want to prove your data is right but for me even if I didn't see any data I'd know there's more people dead and dying that I've ever seen ! Sure you only have to look at the amount if ambulances on the roads everyday..at least 7 I count on most trips on naas Rd
We are agreed that many have anecdotally noticed increased incidences in their circles and I also agree the data shows significant excess mortality. Nevertheless, Patrick’s claims of double-digit excess deaths are unrealistic.
I’m afraid Ireland’s unfolding demographic changes with an aging and growing population will see annual deaths increase even further in the coming years (as CSO, Eurostat, and others have long predicted). So it unfortunately won’t be unexpected to see the number of death notices in RIP continue to rise.
Hi Paddy, I most certainly can make a statement like that as I have backed it up with thousands of words and detailed data analysis over at my substack. For example see the graph linked in my reply to Louise below 👇
I agree Ireland has suffered excess mortality, but NOT to the extent claimed by Patrick.
The basic methodological flaw of Patrick's analysis (and also that of CSO, Actuaries of Ireland, OECD, etc.) is one of using unrealistic estimates of EXPECTED deaths as a baseline for calculating estimates of EXCESS deaths.
Patrick is using the dashed blue line as his reference for Expected Deaths which systematically over-estimates excess deaths (the distance from dashed blue line up to red and lilac lines)
Already pre-pandemic both CSO and Eurostat EXPECTED Irish deaths to rise significantly (green and blue solid lines) these are much more meaningful baselines for estimating excess deaths.
Hopefully this will get plenty of attention.
Speaking of vaccines, as and from 1st Sept 2024 the RSV vaccine is being offered/pushed on all new born babies in Ireland. Extremely worrying.
The medical miscreants are still pushing to have their genetic countermeasures forced on us in the name of 'public health'.
It might be time to wake up from the illusion of 'public' health. Health is 100% an individual matter, because only you as an individual can determine which of two alternative outcomes is your preference. Medical interventions have an associated risk/reward quotient that is never known, but can be estimated. The choice of which risk to take with your own body is ~ by rights ~ yours alone.
The concept of 'public health' has to be finally extinguished and buried, not only based on the empirical evidence that governments murder millions, but on the principle of individual human rights.
This, my body, is not yours to command.
Be interesting to see who (if any) shows up from legacy media.
The neurologist should be named.
Too many doctors humiliate and ridicule the vaccine injured. It’s abhorrent.
His lack of knowledge & education is no excuse not in the internet age. If lay people can equip themselves with information to understand vaccines harm then ‘medics’ can do the same , but it requires them to leave their egos to one side.
It's a cult and they believe this stuff with a religious fervor. There is a general tendency to ridicule anyone who dares to question the tenets of their dogma.
Or as my friends say..a bunch of c u next tuesdays..
One thing I have taken away from all of this outrage is that the medical profession as a whole is at an all time low. For me they are a necessary evil. I no longer trust them. It's as simple as that. They have allowed themselves to be used in a very cynical manner and the attitude of the "neurologist" seems to be typical I'm afraid.
There was a time up until quite recently that I held doctors in high esteem. 2020 has proven to me at any rate that most are cowards that crumpled under the slightest pressure.
There are of course a few( very few) who stood up for their patients but by and large the rest threw their patients under the bus to save their careers.
I wish their victims well but I don't expect any redress.
We must face the fact the sauce WAS effective and the results seen are precisely what was intended.
and they dare to call us a cult.
Is it not the time to start naming and shaming . The neurologist in this story should be named ,he should be made to answer for his ignorance and callousness. If tlhis story is true which I believe it is ,there is nothing to fear.
Patrick E Walsh's substack reporting unfortunately significantly overestimates Irish excess deaths figures. Such exaggerated claims may undermine legitimate criticism of the Covid-19 response by the Irish authorities and the need for an official inquiry.
I've discussed this claim with him. His figures, to my mind, are accurate and backed by multiple others
Well, Patrick conceded in his presentation today that using CSO (2018) projections of annual deaths as a baseline results in excess deaths of 8%~9% for 2021-2022, significantly lower than his claim of 15%~18%.
For 2021-2023, using CSO (2018) projections results in excess deaths of ~7% (or ~7,000) - a far cry from the ~16,000 he normally claims.
I agree Ireland has seen significant excess mortality since the vaccine rollout, but NOT to the extent claimed by Patrick.
EXCESS_Mortality = EXPECTED_Mortality - ACTUAL_Mortality
It's not quite that his figures are not accurate, it's that his methodology is not meaningful. For ESTIMATES of excess deaths to be meaningful and realistic they must consider trends and changes in population Size, Age-Structure, and Life-Expectancy when calculating EXPECTED levels of mortality.
Because Patrick's analysis effectively ignores these aspects, he significantly over-estimates excess deaths since the pandemic. Patrick's figures for Ireland's Expected Mortality are not realistic, they are significantly low, and they ARE NOT backed by multiple others!
I remain happy to you talk you through the data by video-call if you would like.
EDIT: One area it seems likely he is right on is that excess mortality in the younger age-groups has been significantly higher than reported.
Regardless of your excess death numbers debate, just look around ! Everyone is either sick or dying suddenly, strokes, heart attacks etc my mother with parkinson's disease which has rapidly accelerated from these shots, she's gone deaf, constant uti, had tia then fell broke hip, dad also diagnosed early this year with prostate cancer! Can you answer that ! It's the poison shot they received! Imo Patrick's data is true representation of the facts ! People are dead and dying from this poison !
Sorry to hear about your mother and dad. I agree people are dead and dying from the Covid-19 vaccines. I hope legitimate criticism and analysis will not get ignored because of blatantly exaggerated claims.
They're not exaggerated imo ! Open your eyes..the people in the 1800s when a vax was rolled out didn't have stats or data but just observed people especially children dying post shot ! That's good enough for me ..I look at RIP every day..who ever heard of died suddenly and unexpectedly pre 2020? Go and request a debate with Patrick then if you want to prove your data is right but for me even if I didn't see any data I'd know there's more people dead and dying that I've ever seen ! Sure you only have to look at the amount if ambulances on the roads everyday..at least 7 I count on most trips on naas Rd
Hi Colette,
We are agreed that many have anecdotally noticed increased incidences in their circles and I also agree the data shows significant excess mortality. Nevertheless, Patrick’s claims of double-digit excess deaths are unrealistic.
I’m afraid Ireland’s unfolding demographic changes with an aging and growing population will see annual deaths increase even further in the coming years (as CSO, Eurostat, and others have long predicted). So it unfortunately won’t be unexpected to see the number of death notices in RIP continue to rise.
You can’t just make a statement like that and not back it up with facts! His research is impeccable and correlates with statistics from US etc.
So if you believe he’s incorrect prove it or button up!
Hi Paddy, I most certainly can make a statement like that as I have backed it up with thousands of words and detailed data analysis over at my substack. For example see the graph linked in my reply to Louise below 👇
I agree Ireland has suffered excess mortality, but NOT to the extent claimed by Patrick.
The basic methodological flaw of Patrick's analysis (and also that of CSO, Actuaries of Ireland, OECD, etc.) is one of using unrealistic estimates of EXPECTED deaths as a baseline for calculating estimates of EXCESS deaths.
Look at this graph: https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fa046aa26-65a5-41f6-8b71-4194bab16da0_1316x1251.png
Taken from my post: https://lostintranslations.substack.com/p/part-5-what-goes-up-must-come-down
Patrick is using the dashed blue line as his reference for Expected Deaths which systematically over-estimates excess deaths (the distance from dashed blue line up to red and lilac lines)
Already pre-pandemic both CSO and Eurostat EXPECTED Irish deaths to rise significantly (green and blue solid lines) these are much more meaningful baselines for estimating excess deaths.